• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content

MarionMade

People, Places, Products, Programs

Visit Us On FacebookVisit Us On TwitterVisit Us On YoutubeCheck Our FeedVisit Us On Instagram
We Are Generous!We Are Presidential!We Are Having Fun!
  • Get Involved
  • About
  • Events
    • MarionMade! 5k Sign Up
  • People
  • Places
  • Products
  • Programs
  • Links
  • Contact

Ghost Stories & True Crime Focus of “Haunted Marion, Ohio”

By Wendy Weichenthal on September 8, 2025

The illustrative book cover for "Haunted Marion, Ohio" includes a photo of the Harding Home with a moony, dark tree and mysterious light eminanting from a second-story window.
Author Josh Simpkins wrote “Haunted Marion, Ohio” after a journey to research local legends, ghost stories and true crime reports.

When his teenage nephew once dismissed Marion as “boring,” his uncle, author Josh Simpkins, quickly disagreed.

“No, Marion is full of fascinating stories!” Simpkins recalled telling his nephew in 2008. He had just returned home after six years in Europe, and his nephew couldn’t understand how he still found Marion interesting.

Ghost Stories Captured in Haunted Marion, Ohio

That conversation sparked an exploration that eventually led to Haunted Marion, Ohio, a book in Arcadia Publishing’s Haunted America series.

“I’ve always been a sucker for ghost stories and unsolved mysteries and true-crime stories,” Simpkins said. “So I started asking friends and family to recount the stories they knew. Marion did not disappoint.”

Among the tales he collected: a statue in Marion Cemetery with glowing eyes, the legend of “Headless Haddie” haunting Camp Owen, and stories of a church in Richland Township that reportedly flickered its lights as teenagers approached in the 1970s.

“I love those stories,” he said. “They’re straight-up legends but rooted in real Marion landmarks.”

A young woman with long brown hair, a plaid full dress with a lace collar, dark ribbon and pearls, sits in a chair.
Nettie Aronhalt is featured in “Haunted Marion, Ohio” (Photo courtesy of the Marion County Historical Society)

For true-crime accounts, Simpkins dove into archives at the Marion Public Library. One of his favorites is the 1879 murder of businessman John Aronholt, whose daughter Nettie was considered the prime suspect until she died by suicide days later. The case remains unsolved.

“At first I was just making notes, collecting old newspaper clippings, talking to people,” Simpkins said. “After a while, I realized I had a lot of material and maybe other people would like to see it. That’s when I started kicking around the idea of launching the Spooky Marion website.”

Deep Marion Roots

A boy in winter jacket pulls a large wagon labeled "Newslife."
Josh Simpkins delivering Newslife in the 1980s on the west end of Marion.

Simpkins grew up on Silver Street in Marion’s west end, surrounded by relatives and a tradition of storytelling.

“No matter what the occasion, everyone swapped stories and tried to one-up the others,” Simpkins said.

After graduating from Marion Harding and earning a bachelor’s degree in English literature from The Ohio State University, he moved to Germany in 2000 to be with his future wife, Sabine, whom he met at a Marion party. The couple married in 2003 and returned to Marion in 2007, but when Simpkins couldn’t find a teaching job, they moved back overseas.

Spooky Marion Blog Led to Haunted Marion Book 

“It broke my heart,” Simpkins said. “Once we were settled back in Germany, I launched the Spooky Marion website, mostly as a way to ease my homesickness.”

In 2010, Arcadia Publishing invited him to expand his work into a book. Haunted Marion, Ohio was published the following year.

“At this point, the book has been out for almost fifteen years,” he said. “I’ve gathered a lot more stories in the meantime. I’d love to put out an updated edition someday.”

Simpkins Today

The author of "Haunted Marion, Ohio" smiles with his wife and two daughters.
From left to right: Helen, Luisa, Sabine and Josh Simpkins

Today, Simpkins lives in Germany with Sabine and their two daughters, Helen and Luisa, but he still updates the website when he can.

“I used to think I would eventually run out of material, but I don’t worry about that anymore,” he said.

And though life abroad has treated him well, Simpkins said Marion remains in his heart.

“It is home to me, and it always will be.”

Book Signing

Simpkins will share some of the highlights of the book with the public on Wed., Sept. 24 at 5:30 p.m. at the Marion Public Library.

MarionMade! is a program of Marion Technical College. 

Recent MarionMade! Stories

  • The Marion Area Humane Society

    If you’ve ever thought about adopting a cat or dog, you’ve likely visited the Marion Area Humane Society. Located at 2264 Richland Road since June of 1984, the shelter has been a staple in the community for Marion residents looking to adopt or surrender cats and dogs. The shelter is operated by passionate staff members […]Read More »
  • The Black Heritage Council

    The Black Heritage Council of Marion County’s objectives are to promote an awareness of African American History and great African Americans to our multicultural society; to provide an environment for sharing cultural values and appreciation of diversity; to inspire community-wide participation in recognition of the outstanding achievement of African Americans; to support the Minority Scholarship […]Read More »
  • Free Little Library

    LITTLE FREE LIBRARY Did you know there are little libraries all over the city? Little Free Library that is. Little Free Library is all about building community, sparking creativity, and inspiring readers. If you look closely as you travel some of the side streets of Marion, you will find a small library offering free books […]Read More »
  • New Art Studio a Creative Haven for All Ages

    She’s not an art therapist.  But, the hands-on creative classes and one-on-one engagement through art can certainly be said to have therapeutic results for the students. Lindsay Criswell opened Branch and Stone Studio last month at 144 West Center Street in downtown Marion, in a large open room behind Stitch & Skein. Spearheaded by two […]Read More »

Share Your MarionMade! Story

Click Here to share your story about MarionMade! people, places, products, and programs!
  • Get Involved
  • About
  • Events
  • People
  • Places
  • Products
  • Programs
  • Links
  • Contact

Marion Area Convention & Visitors Bureau Downtown Marion Love INC Marion Public Library Marion Area Chamber of Commerce Marion CANDO! Marion Community Foundation United Way of Marion County Marion Technical College

© 2025 · MarionMade! is a community initiative led by Marion Technical College · Website is powered by Neighborhood Image