• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content

MarionMade

People, Places, Products, Programs

Visit Us On FacebookVisit Us On TwitterVisit Us On YoutubeCheck Our FeedVisit Us On Instagram
We Are Having Fun!We Are Generous!We Are Presidential!
  • Get Involved
  • About
  • Events
    • MarionMade! 5k Sign Up
  • People
  • Places
  • Products
  • Programs
  • Links
  • Contact

Entrepreneur Returns Home to Be a Part of Marion’s Future

By Wendy Weichenthal on June 26, 2023

Katie Grimes’ family has been in Marion for generations. She was born here to Michael and Mary Anne (Frericks) Grimes. She attended St. Mary’s Catholic School before graduating from Harding High School in 2001.

“I’ve always had extreme love for Marion,” Grimes said.

Grimes went to the University of Notre Dame in Indiana. She taught high school in in Chicago before moving to Philadelphia to become a tenured professor of theology at Villanova University. However, the bright lights of big cities didn’t compare to her hometown.

“It was always a dream of mine to move back to Marion,” Grimes said. “Once we started having kids, that feeling intensified. Why are we living so far away from family?”

Grimes and her family moved home.

“It is worth it so my kids can spend Saturdays with their grandma,” Grimes said.

While her children Samuel, Seamus, Mara, and Rory are enjoying being spoiled by their extended family, Grimes also wanted to be a part of Marion’s growing business community. She decided to change careers and follow her father’s footsteps into the insurance industry.

Katie and two Shamrock Insurance stand outside the brick building under a green awning.
From left to right: Diane Tanner, Katie Grimes and Patty Flannigan. The team at Shamrock Insurance, 114 W. Church Street, has served the Marion community for 75 years.

Shamrock Insurance

In 1987, Michael Grimes bought McAndrew Insurance Agency, which had served Marion since World War II. The Irishman renamed it Shamrock Insurance. He continued its family-owned, independent tradition until his death in 2019. Katie is glad to follow in her father’s footsteps.

“I’ve fallen in love with insurance,” Grimes said. “Dad valued and loved our community.”

A black-and-white photo of a white man with short, dark hair, a smile, and a suit and tie.
Michael Sean Grimes took a road trip with friends to Marion, Ohio in and met Mary Anne Frericks and fell in love at first sight. He married her in 1982. They raised their three children in Marion. The attorney started his own law firm and bought Shamrock Insurance, which he operated for more than 30 years.

Katie Grimes managed both her father’s business at 114 W. Church Street in Marion and Herr Insurance Agency at 419 E. Church Street, for several years. Herr is another independent, locally-owned agency founded/managed by Bob Herr. A few weeks ago, she bought both businesses.

Katie and her team smile outside the Herrr Insurance Agency office, next to a large sign.
From left to right: Lisa Zirger, Katie Grimes, Amy Justice and Vicki Craycraft.

“I’m a product of Marion’s past. I’m all in on Marion’s future,” Grimes said.

Family Tradition Continues

Grimes and her team continue the 75-year tradition of serving Marion residents by offering property, casualty, home, auto, rental and commercial insurance. She and her team provide personal service and attention to their clients.

“Marion has a wonderfully diverse community with people from all ages and walks of life. We try to meet the customer where they are,” Grimes said. “We don’t judge if you have had driving mistakes and have to carry extra driving insurance.”

Grimes prides herself on her integrity. She and her team take time to explain different coverage and pricing options.

“We want to educate the buyer about what they are getting. While a lot of people are shopping for the best prices, many don’t realize that lower prices can mean less coverage until they have a claim,” Grimes said. “I don’t want anyone to get a surprise when they are dealing with a stressful situation.”

Others agree.

“It doesn’t pay to go cheap on insurance,” said local life insurance agent Marty Stansbery. “If you’re underinsured and you have to file a claim, it can set your family or your business back years.”

Diane Watson has known Katie Grimes for decades.

“I’ve known Katie forever,” Watson said. “It’s great to hear of someone coming back home, being drawn back to our community.”

“I don’t just want to raise my kids here but to be a part of the community and ensure Marion’s future,” Grimes said.

More Information

For more information, call Katie Grimes and the Shamrock Insurance team at (740) 382-3516 or go to https://shamrockmarion.com. The Herr Insurance Agency can be reached at (740) 383-3333 or https://herrinsurance.com.

Recent MarionMade! Stories

  • Norman Thomas

    Minister. Socialist. Pacifist. And, six-time presidential candidate. Norman Thomas may easily be the most notable, unheard of man from Marion, Ohio.  Born in 1884, Norman Thomas lived in Marion for the first 18 years of his life–working as a paper carrier for The  Marion Star and graduating from Marion High School. After high school, Thomas’ […]Read More »
  • Marion Community Foundation

    Marion Community Foundation has been, since even before its inception, focused on caring for the community of Marion, Ohio. What is now known as Marion Community Foundation began in healthcare as the MedCenter Hospital Foundation. Jumping back even further, its roots can be traced to 1957 when Dr. Frederick Smith and Dr. Philip Smith created […]Read More »
  • Nurse and Marathoner Left a Legacy of Health

    A Marion woman died at age 92 but leaves a long legacy of health and helping patients. Nancy Cline was among the first graduating class of nurses at Marion Technical College in 1973. The family came together to help Nancy succeed. She had two children: Bill and Terry. “I was in high school. I did […]Read More »
  • CVB Tourism Appreciation Breakfast

    ANNUAL MARION CVB TOURISM APPRECIATION BREAKFAST National Travel and Tourism Week is known to have many tourism-related events, such as the Marion Area Convention & Visitors Bureau’s (MCVB) annual Tourism Appreciation Breakfast. The annual breakfast includes local businesses, organizations, and community leaders coming together to learn about the previous year’s economic impact in the tourism […]Read More »

Share Your MarionMade! Story

Click Here to share your story about MarionMade! people, places, products, and programs!
  • Get Involved
  • About
  • Events
  • People
  • Places
  • Products
  • Programs
  • Links
  • Contact

Marion Area Convention & Visitors Bureau Downtown Marion Love INC Marion Public Library Marion Area Chamber of Commerce Marion CANDO! Marion Community Foundation United Way of Marion County Marion Technical College

© 2025 · MarionMade! is a community initiative led by Marion Technical College · Website is powered by Neighborhood Image