• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content

MarionMade

People, Places, Products, Programs

Visit Us On FacebookVisit Us On TwitterVisit Us On YoutubeCheck Our FeedVisit Us On Instagram
We Are Generous!We Are Presidential!We Are Having Fun!
  • Get Involved
  • About
  • Events
    • MarionMade! 5k Sign Up
  • People
  • Places
  • Products
  • Programs
  • Links
  • Contact

Memories of the Isaly Shoppe and Dairy

By Wendy Weichenthal on May 8, 2023

One family with an entrepreneurial spirit created thousands of local jobs, invented the Klondike bar and served up meals and memories to many residents. The Isaly family evolved with the changing times by providing fresh milk during World War I, steady employment during the Great Depression, affordable meals at lunch counters in the 1950s and sweet treats at the Isaly Shoppe until the 1990s.

The Isaly Dairy

The black-and-white photo shows two men standing next to a wagon with "the Isaly Dairy Co. - Pasteurized milk & Cream; Phone - 4289" on the side. It is bulled by a black horse. The two white men wear long-sleeved, collared, button up shirts and dark pants. One man holds a wire basket with two milk bottles in it. One man has a hat and the other has a mustache. the dirt road is surrounded by wildflowers. Several houses are visible in the background.

In 1914, William Isaly of Mansfield bought the Marion Pure Milk Company to expand his milk business. Milkmen delivered bottles at local homes from horse-pulled wagons each day. Charles and Bertie Isaly married and moved to Marion to manage the local operation and raise their seven children.

The company thrived, providing stable jobs for local workers through the Great Depression and World War II.

New Dairy Plant and Luncheonettes

In 1947, the Isalys opened a plant on East Center Street. This modern dairy plant provided milk across three states.

Rows of white and black motorized delivery vehicles stand outside the plant. The drivers standing next to each one have white short-sleeved shirts, white pants rolled at the cuff, and some have a black satchel or are holding a hat. The trucks and the building have "Isaly" on the sides. The factory is made of light bricks with rounded corners and block glass widows.

“When I was growing up, I would run into people all of the time who said, ‘I used to work at the dairy,’” recalled Lorraine Isaly Barker, granddaughter of Charles and Bertie.

The Isaly family added a luncheonette on South Main Street in 1945 and another on Prospect Street in 1950. Customers at the counter ordered chipped chopped ham sandwiches, sodas, and the towering Skyscraper ice cream cone. They also served Klondike bars, which the Isaly family invented in the 1920s and made by hand.

The Isaly Shoppe

John and Nancy Isaly continued the family’s entrepreneurial tradition when they opened the Isaly Shoppe on Mt. Vernon Avenue in 1968.

John Isaly was an Army veteran with degrees from Harding High School and Cornell University. He cared about every detail of the restaurant, from surveying the land to build the restaurant to every aspect of the customer experience.

The Isaly Shoppe on Mt. Vernon Avenue had the feel of a 1950s’s diner. Behind the booths, the kitchen is visible with soft serve machines, bananas, a microwave, and more.
The Isaly Shoppe

“My father was there all the time. Nobody ever worked harder at anything than him. He had a lot of attention to detail. He tried to exceed people’s expectations,” Barker said. “My father was a man of really utmost integrity. He was very personable. He liked people. He also liked things being right. Right meant in order, clean, high quality. He was always fair. He really did care about the people who worked with him and for him.”

John Isaly managed the restaurant while Nancy kept the books. The servers included their four daughters. The youngest daughter, Melissa, insisted that if her older sisters could wait on tables, she could, too. The 10-year-old donned a big white apron to serve one or two tables each Sunday.

“Missy couldn’t even reach the food coming off the grill. We all had to help her out,” Barker recalled. “My sister made twice the tips that everyone else did.”

Customers lined up for the all-you-can-eat fish fry each Wednesday. While many enjoyed the burgers and platters, the Isaly Shoppe was known for its desserts including Klondike bars and tin roof sundaes.

A metal dish holds bananas, eight scoops of ice cream, four types of syrup, whipped cream and a cherry.
The famous “I’ll never see my feet again” banana split

Customers with large appetites could try the “I’ll never see my feet again” banana split which was piled high with eight scoops of ice cream, whipped cream, cherries, and four types of syrup. Diners who finished the massive dessert were awarded T-shirts to proclaim their victory in the food challenge.

“I made many of those back in the day!” remembered Tami Galloway.

“It was one of my favorite restaurants. My grandmother took me there often,” another Marion resident said.

Neighborhood children remembered saving their allowance to get sundaes at Isaly’s.

“What could be better, growing up as a kid, than to serve ice cream to people? What a great life!” Barker remembers.

After decades of hard work, John Isaly retired in 1995 and closed the local landmark. John and Nancy celebrated 60 years of marriage before they passed away. Their daughters left Marion after graduating from Harding High School.

“Even though we’re gone now, our roots in the community are very long,” Barker said.

Recent MarionMade! Stories

  • Jean Obenour

    JEAN OBENOUR. You could say that Jean Obenour has been an accountant all her life. Even at an early age, while her father worked as an accountant for Ford, she would tag along and be fascinated by the crank-operated cash register. That interest never disappeared, leading to her pursuit of a Degree in Business from […]Read More »
  • Ridgedale Lions Club

    The Ridgedale Lions Club has been serving the community since 1964 and is one of six Lions Clubs in Marion County. Each of the local Lions clubs is part of Lions Clubs International, which is the largest service organization in the world with over 1.4 million members. Their mission is to empower volunteers to serve […]Read More »
  • Naturalist Encourages Community to Enjoy Local Beauty

    James Anderson is a naturalist with the Marion County Parks District, but he doesn’t solely promote the county parks. “We promote all of our green spaces. I want people to get out and enjoy the outdoors and the wildlife,” Anderson said. “We are really lucky to have dozens of parks and green spaces and so […]Read More »
  • Marion Senior Center Helps Seniors Thrive

    One call to the Marion Senior Center can open doors to transportation, social services and fun. The center serves thousands of Marion County residents ages 60 and older. “I tell our drivers to treat the clients the way they want their own mother to be treated,” Steve Badertscher, director of the Marion Senior Center. 10,000 […]Read More »

Share Your MarionMade! Story

Click Here to share your story about MarionMade! people, places, products, and programs!
  • Get Involved
  • About
  • Events
  • People
  • Places
  • Products
  • Programs
  • Links
  • Contact

Marion Area Convention & Visitors Bureau Downtown Marion Love INC Marion Public Library Marion Area Chamber of Commerce Marion CANDO! Marion Community Foundation United Way of Marion County Marion Technical College

© 2025 · MarionMade! is a community initiative led by Marion Technical College · Website is powered by Neighborhood Image